Birds That Sing With Their Wings to Woo

New Haven, Conn. — In the courtship dance of male Club-winged Manakins, Machaeropterus deliciosus, rubbing and vibrating specialized wing feathers together creates a courting melody to attract their mates, according to a report in Science.

Since Darwin proposed his theories of selection and evolution, it has been posed that sounds made by the feathers of some birds evolved by sexual selection. Richard O. Prum, the William Robertson Coe Professor of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at Yale, and his former student Kimberly S. Bostwick, a curator in the birds and mammals division of Cornell’s Museum of Vertebrates and a research associate in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, describe a mechanism unique among vertebrates that supports this theory.

Using high-speed digital video recordings of the courtship displays, they show that males produce sustained, harmonic tones by rubbing together secondary wing feathers. These highly specialized feathers have shafts that are enlarged hollow, club-like structures. They are bent and slightly twisted so that the ends can touch each other creating a ringing “Tick–Tick–Ting” song (see link to video clip) when rubbed together.

As loud as a typical bird vocal song, the wing song is easily heard tens of meters away. The “tick” notes are sharp clicks, and the “ting” is a sustained, violin-like note that lasts about one third of a second. “It is a bit like running your finger over a comb,” said Prum, who as thesis advisor of the project was initially skeptical of the “comb” idea.

“We ruled out a lot of hypotheses” said Bostwick, “but when I realized that the wing feathers were twisted in a way that forced them rub, I knew we had something.”

“The extensive modification of feathers in these unusual structures implies a high degree of selective evolutionary pressure,” said Prum. “It must be a very romantic song.”

Bostwick who studied courting and sexual attraction behavior in several species of this bird family, previously reported on one that sings less spectacularly, but claps and has a courting dance that resembles Michael Jackson’s “moonwalk.” see video clip >

She said, “Nature is more miraculous than we know. It amazing that we can walk into a woods — or jungle — and find this kind of beauty and diversity.”

A National Science Foundation Grant funded this study.

Citation: Science 309: (29 July 2005)